Tasveer Adance: 49 TO 51

Directing: B
Writing: B+
Cinematography: B
Editing: B+

Grief is different for everyone, and I was glad to see this notion stressed in 49 to 51, a documentary feature about the experience of someone suffering the loss of a loved one to suicide. In spite of it being an oft-repeated sentiment, it really can’t be repeated enough. I had an aunt once tell me that there are many ways to express grief, “all correct,” and it was something I found equally comforting and beautiful.

A significant qualifier in 49 to 51, however, is that there are also different and identifiable types of grief, and grieving loss to suicide is a very particular one. Director Ambalika Khadria, in her feature film debut, finds a fascinating subject to focus on: Indian-American mental health advocate Pooja Mehta, who herself has experienced suicidal ideation and speaks openly about her own suicide attempts—but this is about how she copes with the suicide of her younger brother, Raj.

49 to 51 is constructed on a “microbudget,” as Khadria herself called it in a post-screening Q&A, and at times, this shows—particularly in the film’s opening moments, which quite slowly ease into the details of Pooja’s family life in the hours and minutes leading up to the specific circumstances his death. Raj himself had no evident history of mental health struggles of his own, and his motivation for this act is an eternal mystery, something that will likely haunt his family for as long as they live.

Pooja talks onscreen about how well she knew her brother, how certain she is he would tell her if he was not well, and that he could not have been himself when he did this. I don’t mean to be argumentative, but what immediately came to my mind is how we can never truly know anyone outside of ourselves, not even our closest family. Raj may have had mental health struggles and simply hid it extraordinarily well. It is also stressed in the film that there is no reliable correlation between mental health and suicide, and I’m not attempting to dispute that. One of many struggles with Raj’s suicide is simply the not knowing. What could possible have motivated him to do this, and evidently so impulsively?

49 to 51 wisely does not dwell on this question, as the focus is on Pooja, and the evolution of her expression of grief, especially in a South Asian family in which suicide is a taboo subject. It’s natural to be curious about Pooja and Raj’s parents, who suffered the tragic loss of their child. But they are much older and far less comfortable discussing such intimate details of their own grief, especially on camera. Khadria worked on this film for roughly five years, and did speak to the parents many times, eventually earning enough trust for them to allow footage of Pooja’s arrival for a visit home in their foyer, and that’s about it. We do get some archival footage of them speaking at Raj’s memorial service, which, among many other scenes in this film, is heartbreaking.

Still, Pooja makes for a uniquely compelling subject in this story, given her own mental health history and her longstanding work as a mental health advocate. Grieving the loss of someone to suicide is already very complex, and this adds a whole new level of complexity. And it would seem that if there is any overall message to this film, it’s an encouragement to talk about grief, both your own, and that of others. More often than not, people actually want to talk about the person they are grieving. Others around those who are grieving are often terrified of doing or saying the wrong thing, but this is not something the person grieving is really thinking about. Just ask them what they need, maybe give them options: do you need space? do you need someone to listen? There can be this idea that this approach is more dangerous territory if the lost loved one took their own life, but it isn’t, really. Suffering in isolation is the worse option.

Pooja is a rather brave person to bare her grief not just so frankly, but on camera. We see footage of her two and three years apart, intercut with each other. In the beginning of the film, it’s very focused on her; as the film progresses, we see her with certain dear friends, or visiting India, or reuniting with the man who ran her survivor’s support group.

49 to 51 won the Best Documentary Feature prize at the Tasveer Film Festival, and I found myself wondering how emotionally taxing it might be for the filmmakers to present and sit through this film over and over again; the post-screening Q&A I attended was deeply insightful but, naturally, pretty melancholy in tone. I hope they have space for joy in their lives, even while immersed in a massive, multi-year project about grief, which likely has people crying—as I did—at every screening. Before the film, they did show a photo of their film festival award, the crew surrounding it from behind with bright smiles. Balance is always good.

The title, 49 to 51, is at least a reference to something a bit more lighthearted, a lovely detail revealed very near the end of the film. The last shot, though, is a deeply impactful and memorable one, involving the curious mixture of heavy grief with a delightful memory filled with uproarious laughter. In the end, this is a film that effectively honors both the departed and those who will always miss them, however complicated the circumstances may be. There is no distribution yet planned for this film, but I do hope it finds a home somewhere that people can access. It’s a rare kind of film that is both a tough sit and also a comfort, particularly if you have grieved a complicated loss.

It’s an oversimplification to call this a tearjerker, but you do probably want to have tissue handy.

Overall: B+

YOU CAN SEE EVERYTHING

Directing: A
Acting: B+
Writing: A
Cinematography: A
Editing: A+

There is a scene quite early on in You Can See Everything that will stay with me for a very long time. Granted, many scenes in You Can See Everything will stay with me for a very long time—but, this one in particular: it has only just started to become apparent how intimately Nathan Fielder, his co-director Lance Oppenheim, and their documentary film crew have been integrated into the daily home lives of Elizabeth Holmes and her boyfriend, Billy Evans. And it’s a brief shot, just a few seconds—but, it’s of Billy taking a shower, brushing his teeth at the same time. Not from behind anything, not even though a frosted glass shower stall door: it’s straight-up, full-frontal, head to toe. Billy Evans, brushing his teeth in the shower, fully naked on camera. It cuts then to Nathan Fielder himself behind the camera capturing that shot, immediately underscoring the uncertainty of what he’s getting himself into with this project.

From the film’s perspective, that very much seems to be the point: this is an example of the so-called “radical access” Holmes and Evans are giving this film crew, months after speaking to no media at all, and only a couple of months before Holmes is set to serve an 11-year prison sentence for fraud. Their position is that they “have nothing to hide,” hence the access. But from Billy Evans’s perspective, in this shot in particular, what is the point? “Radical access” does not have to mean everything short of watching them have sex or use the toilet on camera, but this seems to be the pointed suggestion. Or is this, perhaps, also a subtle kind of posturing, a strangely misguided display of dominance?

This, among a great many things in You Can See Everything, is up for debate—and a big reason why this film is essential viewing. Rare indeed is the documentary feature that astonishes at this level, with this consistency. It has to be seen to be believed, and I have never before seen a film in the documentary genre that begs not to be spoiled. Usually spoilers are moot with documentary filmmaking, because they tell a story that’s already been reported. Except You Can See Everything slowly turns into the story of its own making, which means it is packed with details you could never see coming. So yes, I suppose telling you Billy Evans appears full-frontal nude on camera is itself a spoiler, but what can I do? I have to tell you some things in order to convince you to see the movie.

I can tell you this: “strangely misguided” is an apt phrase for virtually everything we see both Holmes and Evans doing and saying. Perhaps the biggest surprise is that Holmes herself is the bigger mystery—it’s almost impossible to decide what to make of her. Is she wildly deluded? Is she the most naive woman on the planet? Is she a supervillain whose greatest power is master manipulation? All of these things seem to be on the table, at all times, from beginning to end.

One thing is certain: Holmes has a brain that functions unlike any other. To call her “neurodivergent” doesn’t even get to the right connotation. In a key scene, Fielder shows her a clip from an old movie to demonstrate how she understands things differently, and even Billy gets on board with the analogy: he’s right, Billy agrees; you do think differently from other people. (I’m dying to tell you what clip Fielder shows her, but this I will not spoil; it’s far too apt, critical, and delicious to the overall story.)

There are times when both of these people seem straight up sociopathic. And this especially evokes some cognitive dissonance because of how warm, welcoming and inviting they are. They both talk about working on a new prototype, the “next step” in developing the very thing that never actually worked—a blood testing device that did not actually work—as if there is any chance that will ever happen. A couple of times we see Elizabeth’s parents visiting, and in one close-up shot of their faces as they listen to them talk about this stuff, it’s as though you’ve never seen sadder people. In the meantime, Elizabeth Holmes is constantly answering questions with wide eyes and a smile so consistent it quickly becomes genuinely creepy.

The film’s title, You Can See Everything, is a direct reference to the “radical access” this film crew is given into their lives—including Fielder’s eventual decision, after some reluctance, to accept the invitation to stay in their guest house. There’s a big difference between watching people’s every move at home and watching them at work, however, and things do get more tense later when Fielder starts asking questions of people outside of the Holmes/Evans household. Evans himself is less mystifying than Holmes is, albeit not by a huge amount—they simply gradually reveal themselves to be mystifying in different ways.

This would be in large part why You Can See Everything justifies its own length: even at two hours and 54 minutes, not a moment onscreen is wasted; there is no filler here. And things take a big turn roughly two thirds of the way through, when Fielder starts getting to know Amanda Seyfried, who played Elizabeth Holmes in the 2022 Hulu miniseries The Dropout. When this turn occured, I found myself quickly drifting into deep skepticism: What is going on here? I don’t know if I like this. And then, this turn quickly reveals itself to be a brilliant device for telling the rest of the story, which is precisely about telling the rest of the story.

You Can See Everything gets to a point where it blurs the line between fact and fiction, fact-finding and fictionalizing. We start to see reenactments of deeply relevant things that happened but were not on camera, which is how this film became the first documentary I have seen in which acting can still be evaluated. We see people talking about the scripts written for the reenactments; we see them reacting to the details revealed in them, evidently while reading and hearing about them for the first time; and we see that intercut with the reenactments themselves.

I spent a lot of this film expecting it to end at the point where Elizabeth Holmes finally goes to prison, because that’s the basic premise set up from the beginning. There are moments when Fielder is openly unsure as to whether he should stay and marinate in whatever akwardness is happening, right up to within a couple of hours of Holmes being taken in. But then You Can See Everything goes far beyond any of this, breaking open far more narrative threads to all of this than you ever thought possible.

Given Nathan Fielder’s history and the ways in which he often inserts himself into his own projects—and it is made very clear that Holmes eagerly invites him into this project having no real sense of his work whatsoever—it’s easy to wonder what extent his own penchant for invention goes in this film. How can a “real” documentary be this beautifully shot, for example? The cinematography by David Bolen—who also shot Primetime, which Lance Oppenheim also directed—is beautiful. This is evident from the very opening shot, of Billy’s face looking up from the lying position in perfect lighting, laying out exactly what we are there expecting to see: an intimate documentary portrait of people claiming they have nothing to hide. (We later watch Amanda Seyfried watching this very same clip.)

Some shots are too gorgeous not to be suspect. We see Nathan Fielder and Amanda Seyfried chatting in comfy chairs in front of a fireplace with burning logs in it—again, beautifully lit. How was this set up? Was this itself at all rehearsed? Did someone just figure out how to create the perfect visual setting for a real-life discussion featuring reactions to the story we are actively watching unfold?

There’s also a curious element of Fielder and Oppenheim being co-directors, but with Fielder being the active onscreen participant and Oppenheim always being the silent director behind the camera—but, presumably both were typically in the room. When we get shots of Fielder holding a camera, someone else is holding a camera to show us that. Whatever is going on, it seems to get normalized very quickly: in another early shot, Elizabeth enters her living room and says “Hi, guys” with a smile, clearly to the whole crew. It’s very rare but there is a couple wide shots showing most of the crew in the room, while Elizabeth and Billy go about their business as though none of them are there.

In spite of it being nearly impossible not to think and wonder about these things, it all works. Oppenheim and Fielder have clearly molded a massive amount of footage into a coherent story—impressively so, given the way it starts to fold in on itself, with people onscreen talking about how this very film got greenlit, how they set it up, and how they are actively putting it together as they go along. Truth, trust, deception, and artistic license are all recurring themes, to the point where this film’s portrait of Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans does change your perception, and maybe even your opinion of them, but does not make them any less jaw-droppingly baffling. Is Elizabeth Holmes acutely aware of everything going on and actually pulling the strings? Is Billy Evans actually manipulating her? Are they both stunning narcissists? Maybe it’s all of the above, but You Can See Everything makes the very act of contemplating it a spectacular experience.

Okay but I can’t tell you everything because you simply have to see it.

Overall: A

Tasveer Advance: HOOP LIKE THIS

Directing: B
Writing: B
Cinematography: B+
Editing: B

What possible insight could I have about this movie? I mean, I watched it, largely due to happenstance, but it’s part of this year’s Tasveer Film Festival and it’s a new film so I’m reviewing it. But I should say right off the top that I am far from this film’s target audience: I am neither South Asian nor do I know the first thing about basketball. Okay, I suppose I know the first thing. You dribble the ball, right? That’s where my knowledge ends. I actually watched this movie thinking about how I have no idea how many points you get for making a basket, nor whether there are other ways to get points in the game. To say I am ignorant of this sport—okay, all sports—would be an understatement.

I gleaned this much: there is an annual tournament with the incredibly creative name of The Basketball Tournament, or “TBT” for short, for which the ultimate winner gets a cash prize of $1 million. Strike that—in 2026 it’s $2 million; but during the couple of years covered by this film, it was $1 million. It’s up the team to decide how that prize gets split up, but you can assume a roster of 12 players, a coach, and staff. Do TBT teams have staff? I have no idea! But if you assume a minimum of 13 people, then that $1 million works out to around $77,000 per person at most. No one discusses this in the documentary.

Anyway, the real subject of Hoop Like This is a very specific team called “India Rising,” comprised exclusively of either people from India or people of Indian descent from around the world—the Indian diaspora—and founded by Gautam Kapur (featured prominently) with the mission of showcasing South Asians in high-level basketball and breaking the stereotype that people of Indian descent are unathletic. India Rising is thus the first-ever Indian professional basketball team.

This film, directed by Shubhangi Shekhar, is broadly speaking a pretty standard sports documentary—the kind that is fine for people not already emotionally invested in its subject (like me) but perhaps a delight for people with direct relevance to it (South Asians; South Asian basketball players). I’m not sure how interested people who love basketball but don’t have much occasion to think about the ways it can be diversified will be, which is unfortunate (either for them, or for my own lack of imagination).

The stuff that interests me here are indeed the more cultural ideas—I am married to a person from India, so there is that angle of personal interest, albeit one that has never had any connection whatsoever to basketball. My husband sometimes watches American football, certainly gets invested in the World Cup (for soccer), and has a working knowledge of cricket—but has never been particularly compelled by basketball. There is a brief but fascinating detour in the film, though, in which Kapur visits India and learns that basketball was first introduced to the country by Canadian YMCA instructor T. Duncan Patton around 1893. It is thus argued that basketball is no more or less “Indian” than cricket.

Moving back to the present day, there are some amusing moments in which players kind of lean into their stereotypes, such as how something like half of them are doctors as a day job, and many of them have family members who own gas stations or drive taxis. We see one if them examining a teammate’s possibly-injured foot. That seems kind of convenient. We also get a few talking-head interviews with certain entertainers of South Asian descent, such as American actor/rapper/singer Utkarsh Ambudkar (Brittany Runs a Marathon, Blindspotting), or comedian and writer Nimesh Patel, among others. Between this and a lot of high-octane needle drops from presumably South Asian musicians, this all feels a bit like a means of upping the film’s “cool” factor. And, to a degree at least, it seems to work.

The period Hoop Like This covers is India Rising’s first and second years in TBT, when they suffered the loss of their very first game the first go-round . . . and then won their first game the second go-round. That second one serves as this film’s climax, as it was widely cited as the “biggest upset in TBT history,” when they defeated the No. 1 Seed and host Red Scare in Dayton. They were then eliminated in the second round, and I have already well established that I know next to nothing about basketball, but I suspect that would mean they still aren’t exactly the best team out there—but, Hoop Like This is quite deliberately not about that (and who would want it to be?), but rather about how they are gradually fulfilling their aforementioned mission, and proving that they can’t just be dismissed or written off.

We do learn that the team, in an effort to be more inclusive of all South Asians, has since been renamed the “Brown Ballers,” and I do wonder if I’m the only one who hears that and just thinks of brown people freeballing. The logo design is the same either way, with the word “Rising” or “Ballers” in standard red lettering at the bottom, below either “India” or “Brown” written in lettering shaped like iced mountain peaks with a basketball rising like the sun behind them. It’s clearly meant to evoke the Himalayas, but, I don’t know, maybe they should find a new marketing consultant. For a split second I wondered why they didn’t just call the film India Rising, until I realized that might only put forth wrong connotations—hence, perhaps, the change in the team name. Still, Hoop Like This is a pretty bland title.

When it all comes down to it, I’m not sure who to recommend this to, aside from South Asians with a marked interest in basketball (or even sports broadly), and maybe the people who love them. Professional sport does nothing for me, but there was enough here to make it a bit more interesting than expected.

Okay so what’s happening here? Is anyone scoring any points? Who designed those outfits?

Overall: B

THE HISTORY OF CONCRETE

Directing: B
Writing: B
Cinematography: B+
Editing: A-

It seems I kind of missed the boat on this John Wilson guy. I never saw his HBO series How To with John Wilson, but if I had, I suspect I would have a more settled expectation of his deeply meta documentary feature, The History of Concrete. Perhaps I should still check it out; it sounds relatively similar. There’s certainly a very odd experience to The History of Concrete if you have no other behind-the-scenes context to it. I left the theater overhearing a couple of young women discuss whether Wilson is “laughing with or laughing at” his subjects. Based on this film alone, it’s genuinely hard to tell, given his evident knack for finding compellingly quirky people—but one hesitates to think he’s laughing at people who are truly no more oddball-nerdy than he is.

Certainly, if you have never experienced John Wilson before, he is an acquired taste. As he apparently did in his TV show, he narrates in the second person, though clearly talking about himself. He also has a very specific and distinctive way of speaking, stopping and starting mid-sentence in ways that often feel unnatural, in a rather nasal voiceover. And the premise of The History of Concrete is hard to put in any succinct way, as early on in the film, Wilson attends a workshop on writing Hallmark movies, then ostensibly tries to apply the rules to this very documentary. He takes such a meandering approach, though, that I can’t even remember how he settled on the topic of concrete. What’s easy to remember are the multiple shots of his own Zoom meetings attempting to secure funding for a project with that title.

It feels serendipitous that I watched Digger and The History of Concrete back to back, as these are perhaps the two most meta films of the year. The latter is actually far more successful at it, if still perhaps less clarified in its own purpose. I don’t know that I’ve ever seen a documentary feature made this way, which is not only in constant commentary on its own construction, but comes across as a documentary form of stream of consciousness. Wilson uses concrete as a jumping off point, and will then wind up somewhere completely unrelated, from a hard rock cover band to the funeral of an elderly Asian woman judge.

The most amazing thing about this movie is that, in the face of every implication from its title, it is never dull. It should be noted that it features very little history (he does travel to Rome where the oldest concrete can be found, but that’s about the extent of it), and in the end this movie really isn’t about concrete. Wilson does constantly come back to concrete, both as jumping-off points and as ways of closing his endlessly tangential narrative threads. He does sprinkle in a good number of interesting things about concrete, but mostly he just gets people’s mostly nonexistent takes on the concrete in the environment around them. With a few exceptions (Rome; Bellefontaine, Ohio; Los Angeles; Brownsville, Texas), the vast majority of the film is shot in New York City. There is a filmmaker out there who could make an actually-compelling film that’s actually about concrete’s history, how it’s used, and what it means to our environment. John Wilson is just not that filmmaker.

The History of Concrete is so meandering that, about halfway through, I really couldn’t decide if I liked it. You begin to wonder: hey, what about all that stuff about applying the lessons of Hallmark movies? Well, in its way, the story being told here actually does come back around to that—as well as other arbitrary rules later applied by other people, such as the potential funding source who evidently misunderstands Wilson’s joke about this being “a rockumentary,” and states that the inclusion of a prominent musician is a condition of their providing funding. In the end, Wilson does discover a connection to a very prominent musician in a way that is genuinely shocking, and gives the film an overall truly unexpected and satisfying conclusion.

There’s something extraordinary about John Wilson’s work, where he can take you from thinking, What am I even watching? to That was actually kind of a blast. The History of Concrete is a visual work of art if nothing else, packed with striking images of regular but memorable people living everyday lives, so skillfully edited together that you have to wonder how much total footage he sifted through to get so many fantastic shots in a clean, 101-minute runtime.

The History of Concrete almost feels like a mockumentary, except its subjects are real, and it falls just short of ever actually mocking them. There’s a strangely consistent humanity to all of the offbeat character on display. It’s unlikely anyone in this film had any idea what John Wilson was actually going for, with the likely exception of Tim Robinson, who makes a split-second appearance at a dinner party in honor of Kim Kardashian. Speaking of which, to say this movie goes in random directions is an understatement, and yet it ends by slowly revealing an evident method to his madness. It’s not often you leave the theater strangely satisfied by how baffling it all was.

It’s more interesting than it looks—especially when it’s not even about what it appears to be.

Overall: B+

YOU HAD TO BE THERE: HOW THE TORONTO GODSPELL IGNITED A COMEDY REVOLUTION, SPREAD LOVE & OVERALLS, AND CREATED A COMMUNITY THAT CHANGED THE WORLD (IN A CANADIAN KIND OF WAY)

Directing: B+
Writing: B+
Cinematography: B
Editing: B+

Between The Cycle of Love and You Had to Be There, I’m not sure I have ever experienced such heartwarming uplift strictly from documentary filmmaking—particularly within the space of just a couple of weeks. People expect “feel-good movies” to be fictional narratives, but this are easily the most “feel-good” of movies I’ve seen all year. It’s too bad so few people will actually see them. This is exactly the kind of uncynical storytelling the world needs.

It’s all about sharing love—and in the case of You Had to Be There, it’s love in many directions: cast mates in a 1972 original production of Godspell in Toronto quickly developing deep love and affection for each other, and individually blossoming over ensuing decades to become truly beloved figures in the entertainment industry. To be fair, there are varying levels of beloved-ness, perhaps sitting at the top including Martin Short; Eugene Levy; and Gilda Radner, who remains a mythical figure in comedy circles nearly forty years after her passing. But this original-run cast of Godspell also included Paul Shaffer; Andrea Martin; and Victor Garber (who is now perhaps best known as the ship designer Thomas Andrews in the 1997 Titanic). Also included in that cast—and all of them giving contemporary intervies for You Had to Be There—are Second City veteran Dave Thomas; Jayne Eastwood; local Toronto performer Rudy Webb (the only Black person in the cast, something not discussed here); Valda Aviks; and Avril Chown.

Chown, as it happens, represents the one moment of darkness in You Had to Be There, revealing apparently for the first time, on camera. the reason she did not stay in the entertainment industry for very long. After Godspell, she was cast as the sole woman on a children’s show with five men, and she was repeatedly sexually assaulted. This turned her off of the industry, but she still keeps in touch with that cast—You Had to Be There ends with what appears to be one of a regular reunion between all of them, still close friends, more than fifty years later. What happened to Chown is clearly an important detail to note, but it does not fit very comfortably within the narrative of this story. That’s not to say it needs to be comfortable, far from it—but, director Nick Davis transitions a bit abruptly from that anecdote, straight into how beloved Gilda Radner was.

Given that the Toronto run of Godspell was in 1972—not the first run of the show, but after only the Off-Broadway debut and a London run, both in 1971—it’s not a huge surprise that all the subjects are now in their seventies or older. I found myself thinking about how much longer these wonderful reunions will be able to continue. You Had to Be There is itself thus a deeply appreciated record of this particular history, of a group of actors who went on to do great things from Second City to Saturday Night Live to SCTV to great film roles and much more. Nick Davis is rather playful with the documentary production, starting with the official, full title: You Had to Be There: How the Toronto Godspell Ignited the Comedy Revolution, Spread Love & Overalls, and Created a Community That Changed the World (in a Canadian Kind of Way). That’s thirty words.

Plenty more people are interviewed for the film, from directors and writers who worked on the play, to a smattering of contemporary, younger artists who speak reverently about the people from the Toronto Godspell. It’s not always clear what connection they have or why they would be especially relevant for inclusion; among the most prominently featured are Lin-Manuel Miranda; Janeane Garofalo; and SNL cast member Heidi Gardner. This rounds out all the interviews a bit, but the clips with present-day interviews with Godspell cast members are by far the most compelling, especially when they are surprised with a video clip of one rehearsal that most of them appear to have no idea ever existed. The emotions and delight it elicits is very touching.

Other than that, and one illegally captured tape recording Martin Short made of a single performance, no footage of this prodiction of Godspell exists. This means a lot of recreation has to happen to break up the talking heads, much of which is rendered in animation flourishes in a very old-school style, kind of like 1970s episodes of Scooby-Doo. Sometimes this is synced to Short’s taped audio, and sometimes it's just matching interview anecdotes. It works fine, if also somewhat transparently a trick for visual filler.

By far more than anything, what makes You Had to Be There work is the chemistry among this cast, how fondly they all remember not just launching their careers with Godspell but decades of resulting friendship. The reunion sequence is the perfect way to conclude this story, as it illustrates a group love that has endured for decades and will live on. I left the theater feeling buoyed by it.

I wish I had been there—disciple clowns and all!

Overall: B+

THE CYCLE OF LOVE

Directing: B+
Acting: B
Writing: B+
Cinematography: B
Editing: B+

If The Cycle of Love isn’t the most earnestly romantic documentary ever made, then it must be close. Director Orlando von Einsiedel does fill about half of the film with narrative recreations of the two lead characters’ pasts, using very pretty young actors and blurring the line between documentary and narrative feature—but, in so doing, he actually intensifies the romance. Much of the literal narration comes from present-day interviews with PK Mahanandia and Lotta von Schedvin, who are also the subjects of the film.

This is the true story of a young man who traveled, in 1977, nearly 7,000 kilometers from Delhi, India to reunite with the traveling Swedish woman he’d fallen in love with in in India at her home in Borås, Sweden. The road distance between these two points is 7,355 km (4,570 miles), but PK was not able to make this trip as a straight shot—he had to bypass Pakistan altogether due to not having a passport, and endured a number of setbacks along the way. He was also offered very moving assistance from kind strangers along the way, allowing him to travel by train in certain segments. What makes his story so distinctive and unique is that he traveled more than half that distance by bicycle.

This couple’s relationship is a matter of public record, but Orlando von Einsiedel’s edit of their story is decidedly coy about their fates. We get present-day interviews with both of them, but we do not see them together. PK is seen in India, and Lotta is seen in a home presumably in Sweden. We see her reading some of the letters PK wrote her while making his journey that took him over four months, and she even comments, through tears, that she hasn’t read them since shortly after receiving them. You spend much of the film wondering if PK didn’t make it all the way there, or maybe he took so long that Lotta was forced to move on and wound up with someone else. It feels very much as though von Einsiedel intended this. The story of this guy riding a bike from India to Europe would be extraordinary no matter what, but amping the intrigue and raising the stakes is what great filmmaking is all about.

Now, is this movie great? I must admit to some ambivalence about it. There is a sort of plaintive tone to much of it, with a pacing that can generously be described as reserved. The Cycle of Love has a 98-minute runtime and it kind of feels like two and a half hours. And yet, by the end it had completely won me over, I was so moved by its purity of heart and uplifting sincerity. It’s extraordinarily rare to see something so completely uncynical.

We do get to see a smattering of film clips and photos from PK’s and Lotta’s youth, but mostly we see flashbacks recreated by actors, who are both decidedly prettier than the real people they are playing: Chirag Lobo as PK; and 24-year-old Norwegian actor Mina Dale as Lotta. We see them meet when Lotta is visiting Delhi after having traveled the so-called “Hippie Trail” for 22 days from Sweden, and she sits for one of PK’s portrait drawings. When Lotta returns to Sweden and PK eventually follows after her on his second-hand bicycle, these very impressive drawn portraits are largely how he supports himself along the way.

Orlando von Einsiedel takes yet another fascinating approach in the construction of this film: Chirag Lobo and Mina Dale are actors, but as we see depictions of PK in the flashback scenes encountering many people along his travels, who are clearly real people and not actors. This raises a lot of questions. Did these people know they were part of a recreation? Did they know Lobo was an actor and not really a guy traveling to Europe to be reunited with the woman he loves? I haven’t found answers yet with the specificity I desire, but it sounds like they simply took a camera crew on a road trip and had conversations with people met along the way, and then creatively and cleverly edited the ineractions into the film’s narrative. Von Einsiedel told The Movable Feast that the real PK traveled along with them, and was moved by experiences not exactly like this own but evidently similar enough.

These sorts of details leave me more impressed with The Cycle of Love as a cinematic accomplishment the more I consider it after the fact. This is a truly unique endeavor, using mostly real people even in recreations made with an actor for a documentary. There may be a solid helping of genuine performance in this film, but its sentiments are entirely genuine. There is even a brief moment of Lobo-as-PK chatting with a diverse array of young people going through letters at a post office, and one of them explains a tattoo to him, which turns out to be in solidarity with a queer friend struggling with the possibility of being disowned by his family. In plenty of other hands, this would come off as corny tokenism, but this is a film of such sincerity that I deeply appreciated it.

There is a quality to The Cycle of Love that might be best described as “you have to be in right mood for it.” And I don’t mean its jarring lack of cynicism and its unapologetic hope for humanity—I mean the somewhat labored way in which the story unfolds. An action movie, this is not; this is the kind of movie you want to quietly marinate in, should that be the vibe that you’re looking for. I must admit that, on this level, I wasn’t quite feeling it for a while. But again, that ending—truly contrived as it was—perfectly landed the plane. If you’ll pardon the discordant metaphor for a movie about a guy on a bike. I left misty-eyed in the best way, and any of the hopeless romantics out there are bound to be moved by PK and Lotta’s incredible story.

You might be taken aback by how charmed you are in the end.

Overall: B+

ARE WE GOOD?

Directing: B
Writing: B+
Cinematography: B
Editing: B

To some people, Marc Maron is endearingly aggravated. To other people, he isn’t. It’s pretty safe to say the former camp will enjoy the documentary Are We Good? It’s probably even safe to say the late director Lynn Shelton would have enjoyed this film, although it likely never would have been made without her, and it certainly would have been a completely different movie had she not died suddenly of acute myeloid leukemia all of two months into the pandemic.

And herein lies the key difference between fans of Marc Maron and people who don’t know him, and how Are We Good? is likely to hit. I was barely familiar with Maron as a standup comic before he started his podcast WTF with Marc Maron in 2009, and I didn’t even learn about the podcast until maybe around 2013. But I had certainly been listening to his twice-weekly podcast for several years by the time Maron was still recording the regular solo intro to his scheduled podcast episode, only days after Shelton’s death. It was heartbreaking to listen to, but in keeping with Maron’s penchant for holding his heart on his sleeve, in ways that ran the gamut of emotions.

The kind of cool trick that director Steven Feinartz does with Are We Good? is show us how Shelton and Maron fell for each other to begin with. An actor friend, as one of several talking heads in this film, refers to Maron as “endearingly fussy,” and says that the more aggravated Maron got, the more it made Shelton laugh. It’s difficult to watch this film and not think about what could have been for these two, who were friends for several years, and then finally allowed themselves to fall into each other. Fans of Marc Maron know well the kind of relationship history he has, and this is one that felt like it could have been the one that truly stuck.

As such, Are We Good? follows two narrative tracks: Maron’s relationship with Lynn Shelton, and particularly how he navigated the grief in the wake of losing her—often in real time, on-camera, and much of it being worked out onstage—and the overall arc of Maron’s career as both a comedian and a podcast host. If you know anything about Maron you know how the podcast was borne of desperation when his comedy career was stalled, and how over just a few short years it both reinvented and reignited his career.

On the other hand, if you know Marc Maron, there’s really nothing to learn from Are We Good? that you didn’t already know. It’s just a pleasant, fun hang with a guy who feel like you know because of this 21st-century concept called parasocial relationships. So what if you don’t know Marc Maron? In that case, this film isn’t really made with you as its target audience. I suppose it’s just as well; the film got special one-night screenings across the country on only October 5 and October 8. I have no idea where it will be found going forward, though presumably it will stream somewhere,

I will say this: Are We Good? is a unique and engaging exploration of grief, how there’s no wrong way to deal with it, and how it affected one of the most lovable straight men who ever existed. That could be the entry point for people unfamiliar with his work. This is a movie squarely aimed at the familiar, however, and while it’s by turns moving and entertaining (and occasionally genuinely funny), it’s fairly short on insight. You’ll get much more out of watching Maron’s own comedy specials, particularly the most recent couple of them (which can be streamed on HBO Max).

I had a good time. I’m glad I went out to see it. But it also left me eager to re-watch the comedy specials, which are far more rightly constructed and have a more clearly defined narrative arc. This illustrates the difference between a comic who has truly honed the skill of his craft, and a documentary filmmaker who is just pretty good at it.

I guess the answer is: yeah, pretty good.

Overall: B

PIECE BY PIECE

Directing: B-
Writing: B-
Cinematography: B
Editing: B+
Animation: B+

Pharrell Williams really wants you to know how pleased with himself he is that he wants the documentary about him and his music career to be a LEGO movie. Lego Pharrell comments on it multiple times, on camera.

It’s cute. And undeniably entertaining. It’s also a transparent tactic, a way for Williams to put up a wall between him and his viewers, so we never really get to know him. Piece by Piece is little more than a broad overview of his three-decade career in hip hop and pop, touching on all of the key beats, tracks and singles Williams worked on or released. Quite the parade of superstars he’s worked with appears onscreen as LEGO talking heads (Snoop Dogg, Justin Timberlake, Gwen Stefani, Busta Rhymes, Timbaland, Jay-Z, and countless more, including Chad Hugo, Williams’s other half in The Neptunes), none of them given enough screen time to offer anything in the way of real insight.

I went to this movie already knowing to expect this. But director and co-writer Morgan Neville really won me over in the first half of the 93-minute runtime, employing clever visual flourishes that can only be possible by animating the stories being told. Some great visual gags get sprinkled into the narrative, some of them LEGO-specific: a young Pharrell watching Star Trek attempts the Vulcan salute, only to discover it’s not possible with his cylindrical LEGO hands. Plenty of other whimsical delights pass across the screen, particularly when talking heads throw out a hypothetical aside, such as E.T. freaking everyone out at the mall.

So, for a good while, I was thinking Piece by Piece was actually much more fun than I had been led to believe. The LEGO animation is very colorful and imaginative, making this a singular moviegoing experience, even among documentaries that play with form and genre.

But later, things get genuinely weird, and not necessarily in a good way. Making a big deal out of the fact that Williams’s wife, Helen Lasichanh, is giving her first-ever on-camera interview doesn’t quite mean as much when we only ever see her as a Lego Lady. And when the content turns serious, it’s easy to become ambiguous about the use of LEGO to tell this story. There’s a moment when Pharrell breaks down crying, in gratitude for all the friends and family that stood by him over the years. A LEGO version of Morgan Neville—who gets a surprising lot of screen time—offers him a box of tissue. Seeing this scene play out among LEGO pieces is fundamentally ridiculous and undermines the impact.

And I haven’t even mentioned the LEGO representations of moments of historic import, including the Martin Luther King rally on the National Mall, and even the protests in Ferguson, Missouri. I saw these scenes flash onscreen and thought: okay, this is bonkers. Outside of these visual references, the vast majority of Piece by Piece renders its subjects with the same childlike joy that we’ve seen in nearly all the characters in previous LEGO movies. Their vocal delivery, as sitting interview subjects, indicates their expressions are much more neutral most of the time, and yet their LEGO selves typically speak with some manner of smiles on their faces.

After a while, this stuff creates a unique sort of cognitive dissonance, even more pronounced by the use of this gimmick to create some distance between Pharrell Williams and those who are interested in him. Certainly nothing in Piece by Piece reveals what makes him tick, or even gives much of a sense of who he truly is as a person. The whole exercise feels like an attempt at having his cake and eating it too: he let someone make a movie about him, but he didn’t have to reveal anything genuine about himself. I’d have settled for some insight into how becoming one of the first superstar producers ever to exist really affected him on a deep level, but, no such luck.

In the end, we’ll just have to let Pharrell Williams’s work speak for itself, which it does plenty well with or without Piece by Piece. As I write this, I am listening to the soundtrack, packed with all the biggest hits he produced along with five new tracks, and that is a spectacular experience, highly recommend. This is a man with jaw dropping talent, in a movie animated by people with incredible talent, and the two just don’t much inform each other. At least we get clever gags like “PG Spray” used in the room where Snoop Dogg is interviewed, keeping things family-friendly in a story about a guy your young children don’t likely know or care about.

Clap along if you feel like LEGO’s what you want to do,

Overall: B

SIFF Advance: MERCHANT IVORY

Directing: B
Writing: B
Cinematography: B
Editing: B+

How could I have gone this long, literally decades, without fully registering that Ismail Merchant, the producer half of the legendary filmmaking duo (and production company) Merchant Ivory, was an Indian man? I need to start paying attention! At this rate, I’ll never become a bona fide elegant gay elder of refined taste.

There was sure a lot of those at the SIFF screening of this film I just attended. This, I suppose, is one of the pitfalls of a documentary portrait of towering figures late in their lives: who else is left around to remember them? Or, at least, to remember their early days?

Ismail Merchant has been dead now for 19 years, having died in 2005, at age 68, after surgery for abdominal ulcers. Thus ended a personal and professional partnership with James Ivory—an American man born in 1928 who grew up in small-town Oregon—that lasted more than forty years. With Merchant producing and Ivory directing, much of the time also working with longtime collaborators writer Ruth Prawer Jhabvala and composer Richard Robbins, they made 44 films together.

A large number of them, of course, were British period films—the very thing they became most well known for, although they did make some films with contemporary settings. The most enduringly famous, however, included A Room with a View (1985); Maurice (1987); Howard’s End (1992); and The Remains of the Day (1993). Many years later, in 2018 James Ivory became the oldest person ever, at age 89, to win an Oscar, for his Adapted Screenplay for Call Me By Your Name, a film that really fits into the Merchant Ivory pantheon, particularly as an updated gay love story.

The gayness of it all is largely explored in this new documentary feature film, Merchant Ivory, directed and co-written by Stephen Soucy. He interviews Ivory himself extensively, inserts many clips of archival interviews with Merchant, and features a star studded array of other subjects from the duo’s storied film history: Hugh Grant, Helena Bonham Carter, Emma Thompson, a characteristically spitfire Vanessa Redgrave, as well as some of the writers and costume designers of the films, among others. There are also some notable absences, including Daniel Day-Lewis (hardly a surprise; he hasn’t given an interview to anyone in years), and Anthony Hopkins, who sued Merchant Ivory for unpaid wages after his performance in the 2009 film The City of Your Final Destination. It was the last of four Merchant Ivory films he was in.

Anyway, Maurice was a groundbreaking film in mainstream gay cinema, especially having come right after the success of A Room with a View. Many of the interview subjects discuss how rightly impressed they are by that accomplishment. Conversely, James Ivory himself is relatively cagey about questions regarding his sexuality—fairly frank in answering some questions, but somewhat evasive in others. Merchant Ivory is, at least in part, a fascinating portrait of a privileged sort of existence among gay men who once lived not exactly closeted, but as an open secret. Ivory and Merchant might as well have been a longtime married couple, but their relationship was not without volatility, with both of them (but evidently, especially Merchant) taking on other temporary lovers as time went on.

The thing about this documentary in particular, is it would qualify as a pretty niche interest. It’s for lovers of sophisticated period dramas, and for anyone interested in the subtle history of queerness in cinema. That does make for a Venn diagram with significant overlap. But outside of that, I’m not sure how much interest this film will hold, especially among younger audiences (and by “younger” I mean, say, younger than 50). Overall cinephiles may find it interesting.

I certainly did, and it compelled me to make a list of Merchant Ivory films I want to revisit, or see for the first time. I have only seen a handful, but of course only a select few would be considered essential in the oeuvre. That said, Merchant Ivory the documentary is fairly simple and straightforward, a compelling document but also mostly something to serve as a jumping-off point. The films they made have a sumptuousness that inherently makes them more interesting than the filmmakers themselves.

The powerhouse Hollywood couple you knew little about.

Overall: B

SIFF Advance: THE RIDE AHEAD

Directing: A-
Writing: A-
Cinematography: B
Editing: A

There’s a moment in The Ride Ahead, about a wheelchair user who in his early twenties uses a communication device to interview other high-profile disability activists and personalities for life advice, when its primary subject, Samuel Habib, is seen observing as a woman at an airport speaks to him off camera. By this point in the film, we’ve gotten to know Samuel well enough that we quickly pick up his irritation, even before his father speaks up for him. The woman off camera is speaking to him is blatantly ignorant of her own deep condescention, to the point that his dad, Dan, pointedly asks her to speak to Samuel like the 21-year-old young man that he is, rather than like he’s five years old.

One can only hope that some people will see a The Ride Ahead and then think twice about how they speak to people with disabilities, and gain some understanding that speech impairment has no correlation with intelligence or maturity. It certainly made me think about how I have related to people with disabilities in the past. A similar moment in the film involves Samuel managing to get in front of then-presidential candidate Joe Biden at a campaign stop in Samuel’s home state of New Hampshire in 2020. Biden speaks to Samuel with relative respect—which is undermined by his decision to stroke Samuel’s cheek. In Samuel’s voiceover narration, entirely spoken through his communication device, he observes: “Why did Joe Biden stroke my face? Weird.”

How many non-disabled people have seen The Ride Ahead and wondered whether they were more impressed with it than they should be, just because it was made in part by a disabled person? This is me, raising my hand. Such things can be difficult to gauge, when you’re aware of internal biases but can’t view yourself objectively. I can only speak to the genuine experience I had with this movie, which is something easily recommended highly to anyone. I also had what I can only assume to be an unusual experience, having also gone to see it with a friend who is a wheelchair user, and observing her reactions, quite clearly feeling validated at a regular cadence.

But here is one of the salient points of The Ride Ahead: people with disabilities have life experiences as diverse as people without disabilities, while facing common challenges in a world that resists fully integrating them, and subject to universalities of human feelings, emotions and ambitions. To get more specific, if you set aside Samuel’s mobility issues and speech impairment, he’s just like any typical American 21-year-old man (well, a straight one, anyway): he wants to go to school, he wants to live independently, he wants to find a girlfriend, he wants to get laid, he wants to watch baseball games.

He also wants to talk to other people with disabilities about how they manage to navigate their own challenges, both different from and similar to his. Samuel mounts two cameras on his 350-pound wheelchair, one facing outward to represent his point of view, and one turned inward to face him. This yields a lot of interesting footage (including, pointedly, the people who condescend to him off camera), but The Ride Ahead also includes cameras held by separate crew, a detail the film never directly addresses.

Samuel is credited as co-director of this film, alongside his father Dan Habib, who is already an established documentary filmmaker. Something that can be easy to lose sight of, because of Samuel being a genuinely impressive young man, is the amount of privilege has also has. How many other kids in their early twenties with the same or a similar condition would have the resources to create a movie like this? That said, sometimes you can use your privilege for good, and I would argue this film is an example of that.

Samuel isn’t exactly a genius—he notes that he gets a 3.0 grade point average, which is fine. But this is largely the point: he’s also not an idiot, and one of the problems is that people treat him like one. One of the people he interviews, Broadway actor Ali Stroker, talks to him about having “ninja patience,” a phrase that clearly struck him, as he repeats it again later. It’s something we all could learn, including when conversing with someone who uses a communication device.

Other people Samuel speaks to, some virtually and some in person, include Maysoon Zayid, a Muslim woman comedian with cerebral palsy; Bob Williams, a principal advisor on the Americans with Disabilities Act along with many other disability activism credits; Andrew Peterson, a marathon runner with slow speech due to fetal alcohol syndrome; and the late, legendary disability rights advocate and wheelchair user Judy Heumann (also featured prominently in the 2020 Netflix documentary Crip Camp), among others. The common thread among all of them is being regularly underestimated, and they all offer their own, varying takes on rising above it.

People with disabilities generally bristle at being pitied, and Samuel Habib has made a film in which he is emblematic of the ambition, drive and defiance of someone who simply redefines what a “normal” life is (“What the hell is ‘normal,’ anyway?”). No one with even a minor inkling of who Samuel is would ever reasonably pity him. It’s tempting to paint him as just a “regular guy,” but regular guys don’t get films made and released. This movie alone stands as an accomplishment, Samuel arguably also being a “nepo baby” notwithstanding. We see his slow but clearly locked-in engagement with the making of this film onscreen, from his education to how he dictates his interview questions for his dad to program into his communication device.

The Ride Ahead clocks in at a tight 93 minutes, including several brief animated interludes that help keep things lively. It’s as entertaining as it is illuminating, and I can think of few better uses of an hour and a half of anyone’s time.

If a rising tide lifts all boats, Samuel is one of the ones making the waves.

Overall: A-